SuppliersPublished

Returns, faulty blanks and who pays for the decoration

A garment fault found after printing costs far more than the garment. What suppliers will and will not cover, and how to inspect so you find out first.

  • 11 min read
  • 1,019 words
Returns, faulty blanks and who pays for the decoration — warehouse at a print shop
Suppliers11 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: Ruchindra Gunasekara / Unsplash
On this page6 sections

The short answer

  • A fault found after decoration costs the garment plus your ink, labour and press time
  • Most suppliers replace the blank; almost none cover the decoration
  • Inspect on receipt — a fault found before printing is a cheap problem
  • Dye migration and shrinkage appear after production and are the expensive ones
  • Ask about decorated-goods policy before you open an account

Blanks arrive faulty occasionally — a flaw in the knit, an off-shade dye lot, a mislabelled size, a seam that did not take. On its own that is a minor commercial fact, and every supplier has a replacement process.

The problem is timing. A fault found in the box costs a garment. The same fault found after you have printed it costs the garment, the ink, the press time, the labour, and the delivery date — and the supplier will usually cover only the first of those.

The real cost of a faulty blank

FoundYou lose
On receiptThe garment, replaced by the supplier
Before printingA little handling time
After printingGarment, ink, press time, labour
After deliveryAll of that, plus a customer conversation
After the customer wore itAll of that, plus reputation

The gap between rows two and three is the entire argument for inspecting on receipt. On a three-colour screen job, the decoration on a single garment carries a share of screens, makeready and press time that dwarfs the blank — and a replacement shirt does not bring any of it back.

The supplier replaces the shirt. Nobody replaces the hour you spent printing it.

Inspecting on receipt

Not every garment — that is not realistic — but enough to catch a systemic problem before it reaches the press.

On every delivery

  • Count against the purchase order, by style, colour and size
  • Check the dye lot is consistent across the boxes
  • Open and inspect a sample from each box, not just the top one
  • Check labels match what is on the garment — mislabelled sizes are common
  • Look for knit flaws, stains, and seam faults on the sample
  • Confirm fibre content on the label, especially for blends

The dye lot check is the one that saves whole orders. Garments from two lots can be visibly different in the same colour, and the difference is often invisible in the box and obvious when forty of them are laid out at an event. If a delivery spans lots, say so to the customer before you print or request a single lot.

The fibre content check matters because it determines the process. A garment labelled cotton that turns out to be a blend will not take DTG the way you expected, and that failure shows up after washing rather than on the press.

Faults that only appear later

Three that inspection cannot catch, and each has a mitigation.

Dye migration. Dye from the garment moves into the print after curing, most commonly turning white ink pink on red or dark polyester. It can appear hours or days after printing. Mitigate with a blocker ink or a lower cure temperature, and always test the specific garment before committing a run.

Shrinkage. A garment that shrinks disproportionately after washing distorts the print. This is a garment-quality issue and it is the customer's first wash that reveals it. Testing a sample through a wash cycle catches it.

Off-shade within a lot. Occasionally garments within one delivery differ slightly. Laying out a sample from each box before printing takes minutes and catches it.

What suppliers actually cover

Policies vary and the pattern is consistent: the blank is replaced, the decoration is not. That is not unreasonable — the supplier did not choose to have it printed — but it means the risk of decorating a faulty garment sits with you.

Some suppliers will contribute toward decoration costs on a clear manufacturing defect, particularly on larger accounts and particularly where you can demonstrate the fault was not detectable on inspection. It is rarely automatic and it is never in the standard terms.

Ask before opening the account

  • What is your policy on decorated goods with a manufacturing fault?
  • How long do I have to report a fault after delivery?
  • Do you need the garment returned, or photographs?
  • Is there a restocking fee on undecorated returns?
  • Who pays return freight?
  • Can I request a single dye lot on an order?

Those answers belong in your notes alongside terms and cut-off times — part of the same picture as choosing a supplier on more than price. A supplier a few cents dearer who contributes on decorated faults may be cheaper across a year.

Making a claim

Quickly and with evidence. Most policies have a reporting window, and a claim made three weeks later is weaker regardless of merit.

What to send

  • Photographs of the fault, in daylight, with something for scale
  • The style, colour, size and lot number from the label
  • Your purchase order and delivery note
  • How many of the delivery are affected
  • What the decoration cost, if you are claiming for it
  • Whether you need replacements or credit — and by when

Say what you need and when. A claim that asks for replacements before Friday because a customer has a deadline gets handled differently from one that simply reports a problem, and suppliers generally would rather solve it than process it.

Reducing the risk

Four habits, none expensive.

Inspect on receipt, sampling from every box. Print a test garment first on any new style, and wash it. Order a few percent over on larger runs, so one fault does not mean a reprint with its own setup. And keep a record of which styles and suppliers have given trouble.

That last one compounds. After a year you will know that one style runs small, another shows dye migration, and one supplier's dye lots vary — and that knowledge should live where the whole team can see it rather than in one person's memory, alongside the substitution rules and second sources. The rest of the suppliers archive assumes you find faults before your press does.

Filed underSuppliers
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on suppliers

All Suppliers articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.