The short answer
- A few cents a garment is dwarfed by one missed delivery
- Ask which warehouse serves you and what its cut-off time is
- Fill rate on a mixed size run matters more than headline stock figures
- Test how they behave when something is short — that is the real product
- Always have a second source qualified for your top ten styles
Supplier selection tends to be decided on a price list, because a price list is the thing that arrives in a comparable format. It is also the least useful basis for the decision. The difference between two suppliers on a midweight tee is typically a few cents, and a few cents across an order is a rounding error against the cost of that order arriving late or short.
What actually differentiates suppliers is how reliably they deliver a complete order to your door in time, and how they behave when they cannot. Neither appears on a price list.
Why is price the wrong thing to lead with?
Run the arithmetic on a 240-piece order. A three-cent difference per garment is $7.20 across the whole job — less than the cost of the phone call you make when a size is missing, and immaterial against the cost of remaking a rush order or losing the customer.
Now consider the cost of failure. A short delivery on a dated job means either a partial shipment, a second setup to run the remainder, or a missed deadline. Any of those costs more than a year of the price difference, and the last one can cost the account.
This is not an argument for ignoring price. It is an argument for treating it as a qualifying criterion rather than the deciding one: get within a sensible band, then decide on reliability.
You do not buy garments from a supplier. You buy the probability that all of them arrive.
What should you ask about fill rate and proximity?
Two concrete questions that most shops never put.
Which warehouse serves my address, and what is its order cut-off? National stock figures are close to meaningless if the stock is three states away. What matters is what is in the building that will actually ship to you, and by what time you must order to have it leave the same day. A supplier with a facility a day closer effectively gives you an extra day of production time on every rush job.
What is your fill rate on a full size run? This is the question that separates suppliers. Having a style in stock is not the same as having it in stock in every size from small to 3XL. Most orders are a mixed size run, and a supplier that reliably ships complete is worth paying a premium for.
| Ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Which warehouse serves me | Determines transit time and rush capability |
| Same-day cut-off time | Sets your real ordering deadline |
| Fill rate on complete size runs | Predicts partial shipments |
| Typical transit days to my address | Feeds directly into your quoted lead times |
| Restock cadence on core styles | Tells you how long a shortage lasts |
Those five answers let you build a genuine lead time rather than an optimistic one, which is what makes a delivery date you can publish on a team store or a company programme.
How do they behave when something is short?
This is the real product, and you can only assess it by watching it happen. Every supplier runs out of things. The difference is whether you find out from them or from a box that arrives light.
Good behaviour is notification before shipping, with options: wait for restock, substitute a comparable style, or ship what is available and follow with the rest. Poor behaviour is a short shipment with a note in the packing list, discovered when someone counts it in your receiving area — by which point your production schedule is already wrong.
Questions that reveal the difference
- "If a size is short, do you contact me before shipping or after?"
- "Can I set a rule — never ship partial without asking?"
- "How quickly do you tell me a style is being discontinued?"
- "Who do I call when an order is wrong, and are they in my time zone?"
- "What is your policy on decorated goods that turn out to be faulty blanks?"
The last one is worth pressing on. A blank with a fault that only appears after decoration is an expensive problem, because the garment cost is now the least of it — your ink, your labour and your press time are gone too. Suppliers vary enormously in how they treat that, and the time to find out is not after it has happened.
What about data and integration?
Increasingly this is a differentiator rather than a bonus. A supplier whose catalogue, stock and pricing you can pull automatically saves you the whole category of problems that comes from a stale storefront — including selling a style that was discontinued months ago.
Ask specifically whether they follow the PromoStandards specification, and whether purchase orders can be submitted programmatically rather than typed into a portal. Both materially reduce administration, and both are now common enough that a supplier without them is choosing not to offer them.
Ask also how often their data updates. A nightly file and a live inventory call are different products, and building a store around the assumption of live data when it refreshes once a day is how a team store commits two hundred people to a colourway that sold out yesterday morning.
How do you test a supplier before committing?
Place real orders before you place important ones. A trial is not a sample request handled by a salesperson; it is an ordinary order going through their ordinary process while you watch the parts that matter.
A three-order trial
- Order one — a straightforward full size run. Did it arrive complete, on the day promised?
- Order two — place it near their cut-off time. Did the cut-off hold?
- Order three — include a style you suspect is thin on stock. How did they tell you?
Record what happened rather than trusting your impression. Three orders will not give you a statistically meaningful fill rate, but they will tell you how the supplier communicates, which is the thing you are actually buying.
Why keep a second source?
Because single-sourcing your core styles is the risk that only becomes visible on the day it goes wrong. A supplier can have a warehouse issue, a system outage or a stock gap on exactly the week your largest order is running, and a shop with no qualified alternative has no move to make.
Qualified means more than knowing another supplier exists. It means you have an account, you know their pricing, and — critically — you have physically compared their equivalent garment against the one you normally run. Two suppliers' "midweight cotton tee" are not the same shirt, and discovering the difference in fit or shade mid-programme is its own problem.
Holding several suppliers' catalogues, stock and pricing in one place — rather than in several portals — is what our supplier catalogue does. For your ten most-used blanks, write down the alternative, its supplier, and how it differs. Keep it where the whole team can see it, so the person who takes the call is not the only one who knows. That list, plus an agreed substitution rule with the customer, turns a supply failure from a crisis into a notification. The rest of the suppliers archive assumes you have a second source and have actually seen the garment.



