SuppliersPublished

You sold a blank that was discontinued in March

Stale catalogue data turns into refunds, apologies and reprints. How to keep a live catalogue honest without checking it by hand.

  • 8 min read
  • 1,295 words
You sold a blank that was discontinued in March — warehouse at a print shop
Suppliers8 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: CHUTTERSNAP / Unsplash
On this page5 sections

The short answer

  • Sync stock nightly, and the product list weekly — they change at different rates
  • Agree substitution rules with the customer at order time, not at the point of failure
  • Hide out-of-stock sizes in the store rather than accepting the order and apologising later
  • Keep a shortlist of second-choice blanks for your ten most-sold styles
  • Tell the customer within an hour of finding out, with an option already attached

The order came in on a Tuesday. The customer picked a heather blend from your online store, chose their sizes, paid, and got a confirmation. On Thursday your supplier told you the colour was discontinued in March. Your catalogue had been showing it for five months, and now you are the one making the phone call.

Nobody in this chain did anything obviously wrong. The supplier updated their catalogue and your store did not. The gap between those two facts is where the refund, the apology and the reprint live, and it is a gap that closes with process rather than with vigilance.

How does stale catalogue data happen?

Supplier catalogues change constantly and quietly. Colours get dropped at the end of a season, styles get replaced by a successor with a nearly identical name and a slightly different fit, and sizes get discontinued in one colour but not others. Stock also moves between warehouses, so a style can show as available nationally while being out of stock in the one warehouse that can reach your customer on time.

Meanwhile your online store holds a copy of that catalogue. The copy was accurate on the day it was imported, and every day after that it drifts a little further from reality. Nothing about the store's behaviour tells you it has drifted — the product page renders, the size dropdown populates, the add-to-cart button works. A store that is confidently wrong looks exactly like a store that is right, which is why this persists in shops that are otherwise well run.

The failure is not that a colour got discontinued. That is normal and will keep happening. The failure is that five months passed without anything checking.

What are the three data problems?

They are genuinely different problems with different rates of change, and treating them as one thing is why most sync setups underperform.

ProblemChangesSync
Stock levelsHourlyNightly, minimum
Product availabilitySeasonallyWeekly
PricingQuarterlyOn supplier notice

Stock levels move constantly and are the least dangerous to get slightly wrong, because a short delay is easier to absorb than a cancellation. Nightly is adequate for most shops. Anything more frequent is a nice-to-have rather than a necessity.

Product availability is the one that produces the phone call in this article's title. It changes far less often, which is exactly why it gets neglected — nothing appears wrong for months, and then something is very wrong. A weekly check comparing your product list against the supplier's takes minutes and prevents the worst class of failure.

Pricing is the quietest of the three. A supplier price rise you do not notice breaks nothing; it simply reduces your margin on every subsequent order until somebody works out why the year was worse than the forecast. It also silently invalidates the largest line in your job cost model, since blanks are usually about three-quarters of it.

A catalogue nobody checks is not a catalogue. It is a five-month-old photograph of one.

What should actually run, and when?

A workable cadence

  • Nightly: stock levels for every product currently listed in a store
  • Nightly: automatically hide any size or colour that has dropped to zero
  • Weekly: compare your product list against the supplier's and flag anything missing
  • Weekly: flag anything you list that the supplier now marks as closeout
  • On notice: re-import pricing and recheck your margins on affected styles
  • Before every team store launches: confirm the specific styles and colours in that store
  • Our supplier catalogue runs the stock and product syncs above automatically

That last item is the highest-value check on the list and the one that takes the least effort. A team store commits you to a specific set of garments for two weeks and produces a single consolidated order at the end. If one of those styles has been discontinued you will not find out until you place the order, by which point two hundred people have chosen sizes in a colour that does not exist.

If your platform cannot do any of this automatically, that is a specific thing to test before you renew it. Ask a vendor what your store shows when their supplier feed goes down, and watch whether they show you the screen or change the subject — it is one of the more revealing questions a demo will not answer on its own.

What are your substitution rules?

Have them agreed before you need them, because the moment you need them is the moment you have the least room to negotiate. A customer asked at order time whether a close equivalent is acceptable will usually say yes without much thought. The same customer asked three days before an event, after being told their chosen garment does not exist, will experience it as a downgrade.

Ask at order time

  • "If this exact colour is unavailable, may we use the nearest match?"
  • "If this style is discontinued, may we substitute an equivalent weight and fit?"
  • "If one size is short, would you prefer to wait or to receive a partial delivery?"

Record the answers against the order. Three yes-or-no questions at the point of sale convert almost every supply failure from a crisis into a routine notification, and they cost you nothing to ask.

Then do the preparatory work. For your ten most-sold blanks, write down a second and third choice with the weight, fit and colour range noted. When a style disappears you are not researching alternatives under time pressure — you are reading a list you made on a quiet afternoon. Keep it where the whole team can see it, because the person who takes the call is not always the person who did the research.

How do you tell the customer?

Within the hour, and never with an open-ended apology. The instinct is to soften the news, which produces a message that explains the problem at length and asks the customer what they would like to do. That is the wrong shape — it transfers the work to them, it invites a slow reply, and it makes the situation feel less controlled than it is.

The message

"Quick update on your order. The heather blue in that style was discontinued by the manufacturer, so I have found you the closest match — same weight, same fit, very slightly lighter blue. I have attached a photo of both side by side. If that works, say the word and we stay on schedule for the 14th. If you would rather see other options, call me and we will sort it out today."

That message does four things in five sentences. It states the problem plainly, presents a solution that is already researched, protects the delivery date, and gives them an easy way out if the substitute is genuinely wrong. Most customers reply with a single word and the order continues.

The ones who do not reply immediately have still been told early enough that there is time to fix it properly. That is the same principle behind every other proactive update you send — telling the customer before they ask costs a sentence, and not telling them costs a phone call. The rest of the suppliers archive assumes your catalogue is being checked by something other than memory.

Filed underSuppliers
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on suppliers

All Suppliers articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.