The short answer
- A 240-piece, 3-colour front print costs roughly $3.96 a piece to produce
- Blanks are 78% of that figure. The remaining 22% is where most shops guess
- Makeready costs the same whether you print 24 shirts or 240
- Screens and reclaim belong to the job, not to general overhead
- At 24 pieces the same job costs $11.71 each — setup has nowhere to hide
Ask three shops what a 240-piece, three-colour front print costs to produce, and you will get three different numbers. None of them will trace back to anything that was actually measured. The price came from a matrix somebody built years ago, adjusted upward once when a job felt tight, and never adjusted back. It has survived because nobody has had a reason to question it, and because the shop is busy enough that the arithmetic never gets done.
That is worth solving, because a pricing model you cannot explain is a pricing model you cannot defend. When a customer pushes back on a quote, you either hold firm without knowing whether you should, or you discount without knowing what it costs you. Neither is a good position to negotiate from. What follows is the same job built from the bottom up, using figures any shop can check against its own week.
| Line | Basis | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Blanks | 240 × midweight tee | $744.00 |
| Screens | 3 × coat, expose, reclaim | $54.00 |
| Makeready | 32 min press + operator | $41.60 |
| Run time | 240 pcs at 320/hr | $58.50 |
| Ink & consumables | 3 colours, full front | $26.40 |
| Spoilage | 3% allowance | $26.85 |
That comes to $951.35, or $3.96 a piece before overhead and margin. The blanks are the largest single line by a wide margin, which is unsurprising and not especially interesting. What matters is the other 22%, because that is the part shops routinely misplace.
One warning about the blanks line before we leave it. It is only as good as your catalogue, and a price you imported eight months ago is not a price. If a style has been repriced or dropped since then you are quoting from fiction, which is a separate and very expensive problem. Check that figure against a live supplier feed before you trust anything built on top of it.
Why are screens a per-job cost?
Three colours means three screens, and each one has to be coated, exposed, washed out, dried and taped before it goes near the press. Call it fifteen minutes of skilled time per screen, plus emulsion, plus the amortised cost of the mesh itself. That is a genuine cost attached to this specific job, and it has one property worth being precise about: it does not shrink when the run gets longer. Whether you print 24 shirts or 2,400, you burn the same three screens.
Most pricing matrices fold screens into the unit price, which quietly does two bad things at once. On a short run it inflates the per-shirt figure until you lose the quote to a shop that has thought about this more carefully. On a long run it hands the customer free setup, because the cost has been spread so thin it has effectively vanished. Neither outcome is deliberate, and both are avoidable.
Recover screens in the setup charge instead, as one line, priced per colour. It makes the quote easier to explain, and it means a customer asking "what if we drop it to two colours?" gets an honest answer rather than a rounded guess. It also exposes something your current matrix probably hides, which is that a fourth colour is a real cost rather than a rounding error. A design quietly needing an extra screen is one of the most common ways a quote goes wrong, and it is almost always discovered at the artwork stage rather than at the pricing stage.
What does makeready actually cost?
Makeready is loading the screens onto the press, registering them against each other, mixing to the right colour and pulling test prints until the first acceptable one comes off. On a well-drilled press running a repeat job with artwork already on file, that is fifteen minutes. On a new job with a customer-supplied colour match and a design that has not been run before, it is closer to forty-five. The variance between those two is enormous, and almost no pricing matrix accounts for it.
That is the single biggest reason short runs lose money, and the mechanism is worth stating plainly. The press time consumed by makeready is identical whether you then print 24 shirts or 240. Only the larger run spreads that fixed block of time across enough pieces for it to disappear into the per-unit price. On a small run it sits there in plain view, and if your matrix does not charge for it, you are absorbing it yourself.
| Job type | Makeready | Cost at $78/hr |
|---|---|---|
| Repeat, artwork on file | 15 min | $19.50 |
| New job, standard colours | 32 min | $41.60 |
| New job, customer colour match | 45 min | $58.50 |
There is a second-order effect in that table worth acting on. Shops that do not measure makeready treat repeat orders and new orders as the same product, which means repeat customers end up subsidising new ones. That is backwards, because your repeat work is genuinely cheaper to produce and carries less risk of a reprint.
Price it to reflect that and you have a defensible reason to give a returning customer a better number, which is far more persuasive than an arbitrary discount. It also gives you something concrete to offer when you want to turn a one-off buyer into a recurring one. That is the arrangement underpinning a recurring team store, where the artwork is already on file and every subsequent run starts from the cheap end of that table.
If your setup charge is the same for one colour and four, it is not a charge. It is a guess.
Why does reclaim belong to this job?
Stripping emulsion, degreasing, drying and re-racking takes fifteen to twenty minutes per screen, plus chemistry. Shops routinely leave this out of the job cost because it happens later in the week, often on a quiet afternoon, and so feels like general maintenance rather than production. That reasoning is understandable and it is wrong. The screen needs reclaiming because this job ran, and if the job had not existed neither would the reclaim.
The consequence of leaving it out is that multi-colour work looks cheaper to produce than it is. That biases your pricing toward exactly the jobs which consume the most labour. Put reclaim into the per-screen figure and the distortion disappears. It is a small number on any single job and a significant one across a year.
What changes on a 24-piece run?
Everything above stays the same except the blanks and the run time. The screens still have to be made, the press still has to be set up, and the screens still have to be reclaimed afterwards. What changes is only how many pieces those fixed costs are divided across, and the result is more dramatic than most people expect.
| 240 pieces | 24 pieces | |
|---|---|---|
| Total cost | $951.35 | $281.05 |
| Cost per piece | $3.96 | $11.71 |
| Setup as % of cost | 10% | 34% |
The per-piece cost nearly triples, and not because the shirts got more expensive. It happens entirely because setup has nowhere to hide. This is the most useful comparison to check your minimum order quantity against, because it shows the point below which a job stops being worth taking at your standard rate. If you regularly accept 12-piece orders at prices built for 200-piece runs, this table explains where the month went.
It also points at a better answer than simply refusing the work, which is to stop putting short runs on the press at all. A dozen pieces is usually cheaper and faster produced digitally, where there are no screens to burn and no registration to set. The crossover between the two methods is worth calculating once rather than deciding by habit.
How do you rebuild your matrix from this?
Start by measuring rather than estimating. Time a real makeready on a new job and on a repeat job, and treat those as two different products, because operationally that is exactly what they are. Time a reclaim. Pull your actual reprint rate from the last quarter instead of using a round number for spoilage, since the round number is almost always optimistic.
None of this takes more than a week of light record-keeping, and it replaces guesswork with something you can defend in front of a customer. If you are also weighing a machine purchase, run the same exercise before you sign anything — cost per print on new equipment is the same arithmetic applied to a different set of fixed costs. Everything else in the pricing archive assumes you have this baseline in place.
Before you rebuild your matrix
- Time a real makeready on a new job and on a repeat — they are different products
- Price screens per colour, recovered in setup, not spread across the unit price
- Put reclaim into the job cost, not into general overhead
- Check your spoilage allowance against your real reprint rate
- Re-run your three most common quantities and see which ones were losing
- Set your minimum order quantity from the arithmetic, not from habit
Holding those figures somewhere the whole team quotes from — rather than in one person's spreadsheet — is what our back-office management does with quoting and job costing. Replace every figure above with your own. The method is the point, not the numbers, and a shop in a different market with different labour rates will land somewhere else entirely. What matters is that the number you quote can be explained line by line, because that changes how it feels to hold your price when somebody pushes back. A customer who has seen the reasoning tends to argue about scope rather than about whether you are expensive, and that is a much better conversation to be having.



