The short answer
- Published fundraiser splits run 5%, 10% and 15%, with some offering up to 25%
- The percentage is meaningless until you know what it is a percentage of
- On-demand stores carry no inventory risk; pre-sell stores earn more per item
- A higher split funded by a higher retail price raises less, because fewer people buy
- Agree the split, the close date and who promotes it before the link goes out
Spirit wear fundraisers are one of the few genuinely repeatable products in decorated apparel. A school runs one every year, the artwork barely changes, and a store that goes well gets renewed without a sales conversation. They are also where a lot of decorators quietly compete on a number that means very little.
The published splits across fundraiser providers sit at 5, 10 or 15 per cent of sales, with some advertising up to 25 per cent and others quoting a flat figure such as 11 per cent returned to the organisation. Those numbers look comparable and frequently are not.
What are the splits actually offered?
| Structure | Typical share | Who carries the risk |
|---|---|---|
| Tiered on-demand | 5% / 10% / 15% | The decorator |
| High-share on-demand | up to 25% | The decorator, at a higher retail price |
| Flat commission | around 11% | The decorator |
| Pre-sell / bulk close | set by the school's own margin | Shared — the school sets the price |
The tiered model usually works the way you would expect: the school picks its level, and the retail price rises with it. A 15 per cent store sells the same hoodie for more than a 5 per cent store. That is a legitimate structure and it should be explained rather than presented as a straight generosity contest.
A percentage of what, exactly?
This is the question that decides everything and it is the one that rarely gets asked. Twenty-five per cent of the garment subtotal is a very different sum to twenty-five per cent of the order total including shipping, or of gross revenue before payment processing.
Work a real example. A hoodie retails at $45 with $8 shipping. At 15 per cent of the garment subtotal the school gets $6.75. At 15 per cent of the full order total it gets $7.95. At 25 per cent of the subtotal it gets $11.25 — but if that 25 per cent tier prices the same hoodie at $52, fewer parents buy, and the school may well finish with less in total.
A higher percentage of a price nobody pays raises nothing.
So the honest way to pitch a fundraiser is not with a percentage. It is with an expected total: a school your size typically sells this many items, at these prices, which returns roughly this much. That is a harder claim to make and a far more useful one, and it is what a treasurer actually needs to put in a budget.
On-demand or pre-sell?
The two models suit different schools and it is worth being clear which you are offering.
On-demand stores stay open, print each item as it sells, and ship direct to the buyer. Nothing is held, nobody collects money, and there is no leftover stock — which is why most fundraiser providers now offer it. The trade-off is cost per item: printing ones and twos means no setup amortisation at all, so the margin per garment is thinner and the retail price has to be higher.
Pre-sell stores open for a fixed window, close, and produce everything in one run. The economics are far better because setup is spread across the whole order, so either the school earns more per item or the price to parents is lower. The cost is that everyone waits until the window closes, and a school that needs garments for a specific date has to plan backwards from it.
| On-demand | Pre-sell | |
|---|---|---|
| Store open | Continuously | Fixed window, hard close |
| Production | Per order | One consolidated run |
| Setup per item | Full, every time | Spread across the run |
| Delivery | Direct to buyer, days | To the school, after close |
| Best for | Year-round availability | Raising the most money |
Many decorators run both: a pre-sell store at the start of the school year when volume is highest, and a permanent on-demand store the rest of the time for latecomers and new families. That combination earns well and answers the school's real need, which is not having to think about it.
How should the store be priced?
Start from your cost and work up, not from a competitor's retail price and work down. On an on-demand store each item carries its full decoration cost, so the arithmetic is straightforward: garment, decoration, packaging, shipping, payment processing, your margin, then the school's share on top.
The temptation is to squeeze your own margin to advertise a higher split. Resist it. A fundraiser priced so tightly that it is unprofitable for you is one you will not want to renew, and these accounts are valuable precisely because they repeat. Better to offer a realistic split with a clear expected total than a headline percentage you resent.
Keep the catalogue short for the same reasons it works on any team store: six to eight items, two colourways sharing an ink set, sizes from youth small through adult 3XL. A long catalogue does not raise more money; it produces more decisions, more setups and more sizes to source.
What actually makes a fundraiser sell?
Distribution, not merchandising. The best-designed store in the world sells nothing if the link reaches forty people. The school has the mailing list, the parents' group chats and the social authority; you have none of those, which is why the promotion has to be theirs.
What to hand the school
- Three pre-written messages with the link, for the launch, the midpoint and the last 48 hours
- A single image showing the products, sized for a group chat
- A short paragraph for the newsletter, already written
- A QR code for printing on a flyer or projecting at an event
- The exact close date, stated in every message
Make all of it copy-and-paste. If the coordinator has to write anything, it slips; if they only have to forward it, it goes out. And tie the launch to something that already gathers people — a first game, an open evening, a term start — because a store launched into a quiet week has no moment to attach itself to.
What should be agreed before the link goes out?
One page, and it should read like a plan rather than a contract. Almost every fundraiser that ends badly does so over something that was assumed.
The agreement
- The split, and explicitly what it is calculated on
- When the school is paid — after close, after delivery, or monthly on a rolling store
- Open and close dates, with no extensions stated plainly
- Delivery — direct to buyers, or bulk to the school office
- Who promotes it, and on which days
- Returns and sizing — handled centrally, not per parent
- Artwork — that the school has the right to use the crest or mascot
- The store itself, on-demand or pre-sell, runs on our storefronts
That last line is worth a moment. School crests, mascots and team names are frequently licensed or trademarked, and the person asking you to print them may not know. Getting written confirmation that they hold the rights costs one sentence and removes a genuine risk from your side.
Then run it like any other job: confirm the order, send a proof, tell them when it is in production, and tell them when it ships. The four messages that remove most status questions work exactly the same on a fundraiser, and a school that never has to chase you is a school that renews. The rest of the stores archive assumes the split is explained and the close date is real.



