The short answer
- Most shops end up with three or four suppliers for good reasons — coverage, stock and terms
- The cost is administrative: separate catalogues, cut-offs, minimums and portals
- Pull them into one catalogue so a garment is chosen on landed cost, not on habit
- Decide who gets an order on stock, then landed cost, then lead time
- Review the mix annually — supplier performance drifts
Almost no decorating shop uses one supplier. Coverage differs, stock differs, one is nearer, one has better terms, and one carries a brand a customer insists on. Ending up with three or four accounts is normal and usually correct.
What is not inevitable is the administrative weight that comes with it, and that is where the cost of multi-sourcing actually falls.
Why shops end up with four
| Reason | What it gets you |
|---|---|
| Brand coverage | Access to the specific garments customers ask for |
| Stock depth | A second source when the first is short |
| Proximity | A day less transit on rush work |
| Terms | Better payment terms on your largest spend |
| Price | Genuine differences on specific styles |
| Specialism | Performance, workwear, promotional items |
Every one of those is a legitimate reason and none is a reason to open an account casually. Each additional supplier adds a catalogue to maintain, a cut-off to remember and a portal to log into, and the fourth one earns its place far less obviously than the second.
The admin problem
Running four accounts by hand means four of everything. Four catalogues that drift out of date at different rates, four stock positions to check, four sets of minimums and free-freight thresholds, and four portals where purchase orders get typed.
The failures that produces are predictable. A garment ordered from a habitual supplier when another had it cheaper or nearer. A store built around a style whose stock was checked in the wrong portal. Freight paid on three small orders that could have been one — which is exactly the saving thresholds exist to give you.
None of these is a mistake anyone made carelessly. They are the natural result of holding four sets of facts in one head under time pressure.
Four suppliers is a sourcing decision. Four portals is an admin decision, and it is optional.
One catalogue
The fix is to stop treating them as four systems. Products, stock and pricing from every supplier pulled into a single catalogue means a garment is chosen on what it actually costs and whether it is actually available — not on which portal was already open.
That is what our product and supplier catalogue is built for: multiple suppliers in one place, with purchase orders raised against whichever one wins. Whatever you use, the properties to insist on are the same.
What a combined catalogue must do
- Show live stock per supplier for the same or equivalent garment
- Carry each supplier's own price breaks, not an averaged figure
- Let you compare a garment across suppliers in one view
- Raise the purchase order against the chosen supplier
- Record which supplier a job's blanks came from
- Hide anything discontinued, from any supplier
The last line matters most. A combined catalogue that keeps offering a style one supplier has dropped has made the stale catalogue problem harder rather than easier, because now it is hidden behind an abstraction.
Deciding who gets an order
A stated order of tests, applied the same way each time, so the decision does not depend on who is placing it.
| Test | Rule |
|---|---|
| 1. Stock | Complete size run available now |
| 2. Landed cost | Garment plus freight plus any fees |
| 3. Lead time | Arrives with production time to spare |
| 4. Consolidation | Can it join an order already going in? |
| 5. Relationship | All else equal, favour the account you want to grow |
Stock first, always. A cheaper garment that arrives incomplete is not cheaper — it is a split production run or a missed date, and either costs more than the difference.
The consolidation test is the one that saves real money and is easiest to forget. Adding a few garments to an order already going to a supplier frequently beats a marginally cheaper price from a second supplier once freight is counted.
Cut-offs and lead times
Every supplier has a same-day order cut-off and a transit time, and both differ. Holding those in your head is where rush jobs go wrong.
Record per supplier, visibly
- Same-day cut-off time, in your time zone
- Which warehouse serves you and its typical transit days
- Order minimum and any small-order fee
- Free-freight threshold
- Whether they ship complete or split by default
- Named contact and their direct line
Put it on the wall or in the system, not in one person's memory. The person placing an urgent order at four in the afternoon needs to know instantly which supplier can still ship today, and that is exactly when nobody wants to go looking.
Reviewing the mix
Annually, from records rather than impressions. Supplier performance drifts — warehouses change, stock depth changes, staff change — and the ranking you set two years ago may no longer hold.
| Look at, per supplier | Tells you |
|---|---|
| Total spend | Where your leverage is |
| Orders shipped complete | Real fill rate |
| Orders late | Whether the lead time you quote is right |
| Faults and claims | Quality, and how they handled it |
| Freight paid | Whether you are hitting thresholds |
| Terms held | Whether a credit limit needs raising |
Use the spend figure in your next terms conversation. A supplier who can see a year of consistent volume and clean payment has a straightforward reason to extend better terms, and asking with the numbers in front of you is a different conversation from asking without them.
If a supplier has drifted — fill rate down, late deliveries up — say so before dropping them. Most will fix it, and a supplier who knows you are measuring behaves differently from one who does not. The rest of the suppliers archive assumes you are choosing per order rather than per habit.



