PricingPublished

Discounts, and when to give them

A discount is the fastest way to give away profit and the easiest concession to make under pressure. When it is a tool and when it is a habit.

  • 12 min read
  • 1,025 words
Discounts, and when to give them — pricing calc at a print shop
Pricing12 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: Jakub Żerdzicki / Unsplash
On this page7 sections

The short answer

  • A discount comes entirely out of profit, not out of revenue
  • Most discounts are given to end an uncomfortable moment, not to win work
  • A discount must buy something — volume, commitment, timing
  • Offering value is almost always better than lowering the price
  • Write a policy, so the answer does not depend on who is asked

Every shop gives discounts, and few can say what they cost. The number feels small in the moment — a little off to secure the order — and it lands directly on the part of the price that was profit.

What a discount costs

The arithmetic is worse than it feels because the discount does not come off the whole price; it comes off what was left after costs.

DiscountOn a 30% margin, profit falls by
5%About a sixth
10%About a third
15%Half
20%Two thirds
30%All of it

A ten per cent discount given casually to secure a job requires roughly fifty per cent more volume to recover the same profit. Almost nobody offering the discount has that in mind.

You are not giving away ten per cent of the price. You are giving away a third of what you were going to make.

Discounts also persist. A customer given a price once expects it again, so a one-off concession quietly becomes their standard rate — and reversing it later is a price increase conversation rather than a return to normal.

Why they get given

The real reasons

  • Somebody asked, and saying no felt confrontational
  • Fear of losing an order to a cheaper quote
  • A quiet week and pressure to book something
  • No confidence that the original price was right
  • Habit — it is how quoting has always been done here
  • Nobody knows what the job actually costs

The last one is the root of most of it. A shop that knows its costs can hold a price with confidence; one that does not is negotiating in the dark and will concede to anyone who pushes — which is exactly what costing a job properly is for.

Legitimate reasons

A discount is fine when it buys something specific. It should be an exchange, not a gift.

ReasonWhat you get
Higher quantityReal efficiency — build it into your breaks
A committed programmePredictable volume across a year
Flexible timingWork that fills a quiet week
Payment up frontCash and no credit risk
Consolidating several ordersOne setup instead of four
A repeat with no new setupGenuinely lower cost

The flexible timing one is undervalued. A customer who will accept delivery in three weeks rather than one lets you schedule around your peaks, and that has real value even though it costs them nothing.

Quantity discounts should already be in your published breaks rather than negotiated case by case. If a customer is asking for a discount at a quantity your break structure already covers, the answer is to show them the structure.

Give something else

When a price cut is not justified, offer value instead. It costs less and frequently satisfies the customer more.

Alternatives to a lower price

  • Free artwork setup on the first order
  • A free sample before committing
  • Individual bagging included
  • Free delivery within a radius
  • A guaranteed price held for twelve months
  • Priority scheduling
  • Extra spares included in the run

A held price is a powerful offer with no immediate cost. Customers value predictability highly, and committing to hold your rate for a year is worth more to a budget holder than a small discount today.

Handling the ask

"Is that your best price?" is a question almost everybody asks and almost nobody expects to succeed. Have an answer ready.

Responses that hold

"That's our price at this quantity. At [higher quantity] it comes down to [$X] — would that work?"

"I can't move on price, but I can include the setup, which saves you [$X]."

"If you can take delivery the following week, I can do [$X]."

Each of those answers the question, offers a route, and keeps the price intact. None require an argument, and all of them are better than an apologetic yes.

Where a customer is genuinely comparing quotes, ask what they are comparing. A cheaper quote is frequently for a different garment, a different number of colours or without setup included, and pointing that out is more useful than matching a price for work you would not be doing.

Charities and schools

These requests are constant and deserve a considered position rather than a decision made per enquiry.

Options

  • A stated modest rate for registered charities, published
  • No discount, but free setup — often equally welcome
  • Support a small number of causes properly rather than everyone slightly
  • An annual budget for donated work, tracked
  • A polite, consistent no

The budgeted approach is the one that works. Deciding in advance what you can give away over a year, and spending it deliberately, is far better than a series of individual decisions that add up to a number nobody chose.

Whatever you decide, apply it consistently. Groups talk to each other, and a school that discovers another school got a better rate has a reasonable complaint — the same principle as any published policy in how you handle trade pricing.

A discount policy

Write down

  • Quantity breaks — published, so they are not negotiations
  • Any standing rates for particular customer types
  • The maximum discretion each person has
  • What must be given in return
  • Who approves anything beyond that
  • That discounts are recorded against the job

Recording them is what makes the policy real. A monthly look at discounts given, alongside the other numbers worth watching, shows whether they are a tool being used deliberately or a leak nobody has noticed.

Expect the first month of recording to be uncomfortable. Most shops find the total larger than anyone would have guessed, spread across dozens of small concessions that each seemed reasonable — and that total is the clearest argument for having a policy at all. The rest of the pricing archive assumes discounts are decisions rather than reflexes.

Filed underPricing
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on pricing

All Pricing articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.