The short answer
- Art time is real labour and is almost never on the invoice
- Draw a published line between a file check and actual design work
- Charge hourly with a minimum, or a flat rate per named task
- Quote art before starting, not after
- Include a set number of revisions and charge beyond it
Ask a decorator what they charge for artwork and a common answer is nothing. Ask how many hours a week somebody spends redrawing logos, chasing files and building mockups, and the answer is usually several — which makes artwork the largest piece of unbilled labour in most shops.
What goes unbilled
| Task | Typical time |
|---|---|
| Checking a supplied file and replying | Minutes |
| Cleaning a low-resolution logo | 15–30 minutes |
| Redrawing a logo as vector | 30 minutes to several hours |
| Separating a multi-colour design | 30–90 minutes |
| Building mockups on garment colours | 15–45 minutes |
| Designing from a description | An hour upwards |
| Revisions after a proof | Unlimited, in practice |
None of that is printing, and all of it happens before a press is touched. On a large order it disappears into the margin; on a small order it can exceed the profit on the job entirely.
If nobody can say how long artwork took, nobody can say whether the job made money.
Free, included, chargeable
The line has to be published, or every conversation becomes a negotiation.
A workable split
- Free: checking a file, telling the customer what is wrong, a straight placement mockup
- Included: scaling and positioning print-ready artwork, standard separations from clean vector
- Chargeable: redrawing, colour reduction, designing from scratch, complex separations, extra revisions
Free items are sales work and should stay free — a customer who gets a straight answer about their file trusts the shop. Chargeable items are production work, and the test is simple: would you be doing this if the customer had sent the right file?
Where the line sits is your decision, but it must be the same for everyone and it must be written down. Charging one customer and not another for the same task is how a policy stops being a policy — the same reasoning as deciding how far to go on customer files.
Rates
Two approaches, and most shops use both.
Hourly with a minimum suits open-ended work. Set a rate reflecting skilled labour rather than shop-floor time, apply a half-hour or one-hour minimum, and bill in sensible increments.
Flat rate per task suits known jobs — a vector redraw, a colour reduction, a set of separations. Customers prefer flat rates because they can decide, and you prefer them once you know how long the task actually takes.
Setting the flat rates
- Time the same task across several real jobs
- Price the typical case, not the fastest one
- Name a rate for anything unusually complex, before starting
- Review the rates when the times drift
Quoting it up front
Art charges are only ever contentious when they arrive as a surprise. Quoted before the work starts, they are almost never questioned.
The message
"The file you've sent won't hold up at this size. I can redraw it properly for [$X] — that's a one-off, you keep the file, and every future order uses it with no art charge. Happy to go ahead on that basis?"
Three things do the work there: a reason, a fixed number, and a future benefit. The customer is buying an asset rather than paying a penalty, and the second order proves the point.
Put art on its own invoice line, always. Folded into the piece price it is invisible, which means it looks like your printing is expensive rather than like your design work has value — and the same visibility argument applies to setup fees.
Revisions
Unlimited revisions are the way a profitable art charge becomes an unprofitable one. State a number.
Two or three rounds covers almost every reasonable customer. Beyond that, charge at your hourly rate and say so in advance — the point is not the revenue, it is that a stated limit makes people consolidate their feedback instead of sending it one thought at a time.
Distinguish between correcting your mistake and changing their mind. A proof that misspells a name is a fix; a decision to try a different colourway is a revision. Getting that distinction into the proof process prevents the argument entirely.
Who owns the file
Say it explicitly, because both answers are defensible and silence is not.
| Position | Effect |
|---|---|
| Customer owns the redraw | Higher charge; they may take it elsewhere |
| Shop retains it | Lower charge; keeps the account |
| Shop retains, release on request | Common middle ground |
| Separations always retained | Reasonable — they are shop-specific |
Separations are genuinely yours: they are built for your mesh counts, inks and press, and they would not help another shop much. The redrawn logo is a different matter, and a customer who paid for it will expect to be given it eventually.
Whichever position you take, keep the files where the whole team can reach them and where the ordering system can use them — artwork attached to the customer record is what turns a paid redraw into an asset that shortens every subsequent order. The rest of the pricing archive assumes art time is quoted before it is spent.
Tracking the time
None of the pricing above survives without knowing how long art actually takes, and almost no shop knows. Guessing produces flat rates that are wrong in both directions — too high on the easy jobs, which loses work, and too low on the difficult ones, which loses money.
Track it for a month. A note on the job record with a start and finish is enough; the aim is a sample, not a timesheet culture. Record the task type alongside the time, because the interesting output is not the total but the spread — which categories of work are consistently underpriced.
Two patterns emerge almost universally. Redraws take substantially longer than shops estimate, often by a factor of two. And revisions, counted honestly, account for more time than the original design on a meaningful share of jobs — which is the strongest argument there is for stating a revision limit.
Attach the outcome to the customer as well as the job. An account that generates three hours of art time on every order is a different proposition from one sending clean vector every time, and that difference belongs in how you price them — the same reasoning as deciding which work to take.



