The short answer
- Six to eight items convert better than twenty — choice creates hesitation
- Cover a price ladder: something cheap, something mid, something premium
- Two colourways sharing one ink set means one setup, not two
- Offer youth sizes only where the audience genuinely includes children
- Leave out anything you have not decorated before
Product selection is the decision that most affects how a store performs, and it is usually made by asking the customer what they want to offer. That produces a long list, because nobody wants to exclude anything, and a long list underperforms a short one.
Your job is to narrow it, and to be able to explain why.
Why fewer items sell more
Because a person opening a store link on a phone, in a group chat, while doing something else, is not shopping — they are completing a task. Twenty items turns that task into a decision, and decisions get postponed.
| Catalogue size | Typical effect |
|---|---|
| 6–8 items | Easy decision, conversion holds |
| 12–15 | More browsing, no more ordering |
| 20+ | Hesitation, abandoned baskets |
It costs you as well. Every extra style is more sizes to source, another stock position to verify before launch, and another opportunity for one item to be unavailable and hold up the order. A short list is better for both sides, which is the first thing to fix on a store that browses well and converts badly.
The core six
A structure that works across schools, clubs and companies:
Six that cover almost everyone
- Short-sleeve tee — the volume item and the price anchor
- Long-sleeve tee — the same design, seasonal appeal
- Pullover hoodie — the highest-value item most stores sell
- Full-zip or crew sweatshirt — for people who will not wear a hood
- Performance tee or polo — for sports and for workplaces
- One accessory — a cap, a tote, a bottle
Add a seventh or eighth only for a reason you can name: a specific sport's requirement, a workplace dress code, a request that came up repeatedly last time. "Variety" is not a reason.
The accessory earns its place by being the item people add. It is usually the lowest-value line and it raises average order value, because someone buying a hoodie will add a $12 cap without much thought.
Colourways and ink sets
Two colourways at most, and both should use the same ink set. This is the single most useful production constraint in store planning and it is invisible to the customer.
If the navy garment and the grey garment take an identical print, you set up once and run both. If a third colourway needs a different underbase or a colour swap, you have doubled setup for a handful of pieces — and setup does not shrink with quantity.
Where a customer wants a light and a dark garment, check whether one design works on both. Often a single-colour print in white on dark and in navy on light is the answer, and that is two ink colours rather than two full setups.
Two colourways on one ink set is one job. Three is two jobs and a longer schedule.
Sizes
Offer the sizes the audience actually contains, and no more. Every size you list is a size you must source, and a store offering youth sizes to an adult workplace is carrying stock risk for nothing.
| Audience | Range |
|---|---|
| Workplace | Adult XS–3XL |
| School or club with families | Youth XS–L plus adult XS–3XL |
| Youth team only | Youth range plus adult S–XL for coaches |
| Event or fundraiser | Adult range; add youth only if children attend |
Check every size exists in the style before launching. Youth sizes in particular are frequently absent from adult-oriented garments, and a store taking orders for a size the supplier does not make produces a problem you cannot solve after the fact — which is why it is on the launch checklist.
Show the size chart for that specific garment, not a generic one. Charts copied between products are worse than none, because people trust them, and the exchanges land on you after delivery.
Build a price ladder
Three price points, deliberately spaced. Something at the low end so nobody is priced out, something in the middle where most orders land, and something premium for the people who want it.
The premium item matters more than its volume suggests. A store with nothing above $30 caps its average order value; adding a heavyweight hoodie or a quality jacket gives the parent or manager who wants to spend more somewhere to do it, and a meaningful minority will.
Keep the ladder visible in the ordering — cheapest first is not always right. Leading with the mid-priced item and showing the premium one alongside performs better than a list ascending from the cheapest, which anchors everyone low.
What to leave out
Do not put these in a store
- Anything you have not decorated before — a store is the wrong place to learn a garment
- Styles with thin stock or a long restock
- Items where the design does not fit the print area
- Anything requiring a different decoration method for one item only
- Garments with a size run you cannot fully source
- A third colourway, unless someone pays for the setup
The first line is worth holding to. A store is a commitment to produce whatever is ordered, and discovering mid-run that a garment behaves badly — a fabric that scorches, a seam under the print area, a colour that shows through — is a problem with no good exit. Test the garment on a sample before it goes in a catalogue.
Once the list is settled, everything else about the store gets easier: stock is checkable in minutes, the artwork is prepared once, and the production run at close is a single job. That is the whole reason to match the structure to the customer before choosing products. The rest of the stores archive assumes a short, tested catalogue.
Reviewing the list after each store
Record what actually sold, by item and by size, the week the store closes. Two or three stores in you will have a pattern that is worth more than any general advice — and it is usually surprising.
Most shops find one item barely sells and one runs short every time. Drop the first, stock deeper on the second, and the next store is both simpler to run and more profitable without any change to the design or the promotion.
Keep the record against the customer so the following year starts from evidence rather than from the same conversation. That is the same reason reorders should start from what is stored rather than from memory.



