BusinessPublished

Working out what a job really earned

The invoice is not the profit. How to allocate garments, labour, setup and overhead to a single job, and what the answer usually reveals.

  • 12 min read
  • 1,026 words
Working out what a job really earned — business office at a print shop
Business12 min readA1printsoft EditorialPhoto: Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash
On this page7 sections

The short answer

  • Revenue minus garment cost is not profit — it omits labour, setup and overhead
  • Allocate overhead by production hours, not by revenue
  • Setup is a per-job cost and it is what makes small orders unprofitable
  • Most shops find one category they are losing on, hidden by an average
  • Do it on ten jobs, not all of them — the pattern appears quickly

Ask a decorator what a job made and the usual answer is the invoice value minus the blanks. That number is easy to produce and it is not profit — it omits everything the shop did to the garments, which is most of the cost.

Working out the real figure on a handful of jobs takes an afternoon and it usually changes what a shop quotes for.

Why the invoice misleads

Because the visible cost is the one that arrives as somebody else's invoice. Blanks come with a bill; press time does not, so it is easy to treat as free.

It is not free. The press cost money, the person running it is paid, the building is rented and the dryer consumes electricity whether the job is large or small. Those are real and they belong to the jobs that used them.

The only cost that arrives as an invoice is the garment. Everything else is just as real.

The four costs

CostBehavesUsually
GarmentsPer pieceLargest single line
Consumables — ink, film, threadPer pieceSmall but real
SetupPer jobWhat kills small orders
Production labourPer hourFrequently omitted
OverheadPer hour, allocatedRent, power, equipment, admin

Setup deserves its own line rather than being spread into a per-piece figure. It does not change with quantity — screens, makeready and reclaim are the same for 24 pieces as for 240 — which is precisely why its share collapses as the run grows.

Allocating overhead

By production hours, not by revenue. Allocating by revenue assumes expensive jobs consume more of the building, which is not true — a long cheap run consumes more shop than a short expensive one.

Working out an hourly overhead rate

  • Total your annual fixed costs: rent, utilities, insurance, equipment finance, admin salaries, software
  • Total your annual productive hours — shifts actually available, not hours open
  • Divide. That is your overhead per production hour
  • Add production labour separately, at the real employment cost

Use productive hours rather than opening hours. A shop open forty hours a week where the press runs twenty-five has an overhead rate based on twenty-five, and using forty understates every job by a third.

Recalculate annually. Rent, energy and wages all move, and an overhead rate from three years ago is quietly making every job look better than it is — the same slow erosion behind prices going stale.

A worked example

Two jobs, same customer, same design, different quantities. Figures are illustrative — substitute your own.

24 pieces240 pieces
Invoice$312.00$1,872.00
Garments$74.40$744.00
Consumables$4.80$32.00
Setup$95.00$95.00
Production labour$46.00$132.00
Overhead$52.00$150.00
Total cost$272.20$1,153.00
Margin$39.80 (13%)$719.00 (38%)

Same design, same customer, same shop — and one job returns thirteen per cent while the other returns thirty-eight. The difference is almost entirely setup, which is identical in both and carried by ten times fewer pieces in the first.

That is the arithmetic behind minimum order quantities. A shop that takes the 24-piece job at that price is not losing money, but it is earning a third of the return for a job that occupies a similar amount of attention.

What it usually reveals

FindingFrequency
Small orders barely break evenAlmost always
One customer's work is unprofitableCommon
Rush jobs cost more than the upliftCommon
Multi-location jobs are underpricedCommon
Reorders are the best margin in the shopAlmost always
The busiest job type is not the best oneFrequent

The reorder finding is the useful one, because it is actionable in a pleasant direction. Repeat work carries no artwork, no separations and faster makeready, so it earns more per hour than anything else — which is a strong argument for spending effort on keeping customers rather than finding new ones.

Doing it routinely

Not on every job — that is a full costing system and most shops do not need one. Do it on a sample, regularly.

A quarterly exercise

  • Pick ten jobs spanning your range of sizes and types
  • Cost each properly, including labour and overhead
  • Rank by margin percentage, not by value
  • Look at the bottom three and ask what they have in common
  • Adjust the price list, the minimum, or which work you accept

Ten jobs is enough for the pattern to appear. The bottom three almost always share something — a quantity band, a customer, a job type — and that shared feature is where a pricing decision belongs.

Holding the cost components against each job as it runs makes this a report rather than an afternoon's work, which is one of the practical arguments for keeping quoting and job costing in one place rather than in a spreadsheet nobody updates. The rest of the business archive assumes you know which of your work actually pays.

What to do with the answer

Costing jobs is only worth the afternoon if something changes afterwards. Four responses cover most findings.

Raise the minimum. If small orders consistently return a fraction of the margin of larger ones, the minimum is in the wrong place. That is an arithmetic decision rather than a judgement about which customers you like.

Reprice a category. Where one job type is consistently poor — multi-location work, rush jobs, one difficult garment — fix the line rather than the individual quote.

Change the process. Sometimes the answer is not price. A quantity band that loses money on screen may be genuinely profitable on a different method, which keeps the customer and the margin.

Decline it. Where none of the above works, the honest conclusion is that the work does not suit your shop, and capacity spent on it is capacity not spent on work that pays.

Filed underBusiness
Share
Written byA1printsoft Editorial
175 articles

The print production desk at A1Printsoft. Writes the practical side of running a decorating shop: what things cost, how long they take and what to charge, checked against published trade figures.

Keep reading

More on business

All Business articles

Set up in an afternoon. From what you already do.

Free for 14 days · no card · pick what you make and we preload the methods, products and price tables.